Showing posts with label Community Engagement. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Community Engagement. Show all posts

Wednesday, October 31, 2018

Dunk2: Electric Boogaloo A.K.A. A Social Media Analysis on Dunkin' Donuts, Part 2

Whether you're reading this the day it was posting or 50 days from now, I refuse to let the fact that today is Halloween slip past. Happy Halloween all you spooky ghosts, ghouls, and goblins that go bump in the night!


PREVIOUSLY ON DANNY'S DUNKIN' ANALYSIS

"DUNKIN' HAS LESS FOLLOWERS THAN
 ALL OF THE COMPANY'S THEY 
CONSIDER COMPETITION"
"THEIR POSTS AND CHANNELS ARE NOT
 AS ENGAGING AS THEY COULD BE"

"TRENDS SHOW THAT DONUTS ARE 
SEARCHED FOR MORE OFTEN THAN 
OTHER PRODUCTS SOLD AT DUNKIN'"

"#DUNKIN' AND THEIR "JUST CALL US
DUNKIN' " CAMPAIGN"
"DUNKIN' NOW SELLS BEER????"


NOW WITHOUT FURTHER ADO, THE SHOW MUST GO ON

If you remember last time, I talked a lot about Dunkin' and how their new campaign to move away from the donut aspect of their name. We went over the different competition that Dunkin' sees as its major threats (McDonalds and Starbucks) and how they as a company compare to those brands. This time, I wanted to take a more technical approach, looking more closely at specific analytics (like certain products or promotions). I also wanted to dive a bit deeper into how Dunkin' has been performing in the engagement category, both indirect through posting and direct through responses.

As you can see, Dunkin' is doing fairly well for themselves compared to when I

Harpoon Beer
Last time I mentioned how Dunkin' partnered with Harpoon Brewing to create a coffee porter beer. I was curious to take a closer look more into that product in regards to both companies. One of the things to note is that this is a partnership. At the time of my introduction of it, I thought it was very much a joint effort, where both companies were doing some form of promotion or acknowledgement of its existence. From my research, I've determined that the beer itself is merely a Harpoon product with the Dunkin' name slapped on the label. There is minimal connection that they partnered together on Dunkin's end, whereas Harpoon advertises the product on the home page of their website. Even their search engine, which is dedicated to finding limited edition ales and tasty beverages alike, shows us where we can find the nearest store to get our alcoholic Dunkin' fix. Harpoon even held a "Dunktoberfest" to celebrate the release of their new Porter. I was only able to find a single mention about this event on any Dunkin' website or social media platform and it was pretty buried beneath their other posts. These are the types of missed opportunities for branching out that Dunkin' continues to fail at capitalizing on.



Interesting to note that Dunkin' isn't showing much off their connection to Harpoon but promoting their new taps at one of their site locations
Social mention searching "coffee porter" (blue) and "Harpoon Brewery" (Red)

Social mention searching "Dunkin Coffee Porter" and "Harpoon Brewery"

Social mention searching "Dunkin' Donuts" and "Harpoon Brewery"

SWOT Analysis
If we're going to analyze what Dunkin' should be doing as they move forward, we need to really dive into what they're currently doing well and what could be done better. This process is also known as a Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities, and Threats analysis or a SWOT analysis. 

Strengths
Let's start with what Dunkin' has going for it. First off, they have a well known brand and have relatively strong logo recognition. We hear Dunkin' and can instantly correlate at least 3 different products we can buy at a store location. Their logos, whether it is the large orange and pink colored "D", the coffee cup, or the man running from his impending calories, all trigger immediate response to who they are.
In addition, when they make promotional advertisements, they're pretty good. Personally, I'm a big fan of this video since its innovative and makes the most of the products Dunkin' has.

Weaknesses
Last time, one of the major weaknesses I brought up was Dunkin's slogan, "America Runs on Dunkin'". Iconic as it may be, this essentially separates Dunkin' as a global company merely due to the fact it cuts out 190+ countries in the process. Doing research on how Dunkin' was doing globally, I stumbled across CNBC's video on one of the countries they've been struggling in, India. If you have the chance, definitely watch the full video as its super informative and gives a really great outlook as to why Dunkin's approach may be falling short.


Another main weakness comes from their responsiveness, especially when it applies to negative comments, critiques, or anything that falls short of praise. In multiple instances on a variety of different posts from Instagram and Facebook, Dunkin' fails to even acknowledge the issues being brought up. From a quick browse of the most recent posts, I've found several comments from different users that, despite showing recognition from fellow viewers, are ignored by Dunkin'. The only times in recent posts that a comment was responded to was when the user did not properly post their costume submission and were redirected to the correct channels.












Meanwhile, Dunkin' continues to actively respond on their Twitter in ways that tend to make them look better. This is seen through helping out customers, apologizing for poor customer service, or merely appreciating customers who are praising their quality.




Opportunities
We just spent the past two paragraphs appreciating what Dunkin' does well, while simultaneously criticizing its failure to succeed. The only next logical step is to take a look at what Dunkin' can and should be doing to truly maximize their outreach.
1) Presence & Interactions:
We spent the past few minutes looking at a brief history of the shortcomings Dunkin' had in regards to responsiveness and engagement, so there isn't much more to say on the matter. They need to start being present when it comes to their customers or they are going to lose them. It's hard to stay loyal to a company that doesn't seem to acknowledge the complaints we've submitted.
2) Partnership:
Dunkin' has done well when working with partners, as seen with promotions and advertisements with New England Patriots or when the Red Sox won the world series this year. The Dunkin'-Harpoon partnership should have worked better. Social media trends prove that there was a definite lack of discussion formed around the product. If this truly was a collaborative effort, show us. People love to talk about companies working together. If Dunkin' capitalizes more on their joint projects, like they did with their Dove sweepstakes campaign, they will utilize the groundswell in ways they haven't in the past.

Threats
With every sunny day comes a dark cloud to brighten the mood. Through Dunkin's rebranding, they leave themselves open to threats from new directions. If they truly see McDonalds and Starbucks as competitors, they need to find ways to stand out from them. Right now, their biggest threat are these new markets they want to enter and the new competition they'll have to face. With donuts in their name, there weren't many claiming for that top spot. We saw in last week's presentation that they dwarf companies like Tim Horton's and Krispy Kreme when it comes to mentions. This is a whole new ballgame Dunkin' wants to play. If they want to succeed, they can't fall flat when they walk out onto that field following the official name change in January.


Final Thoughts
Last time, I gave a verdict on what I thought of Dunkin'. This time, I want to give my concluding thoughts to their promotions and tactics. Overall, Dunkin' falls short of earning praise. They are not capitalizing on the opportunities that present themselves and this is a worrying trend. When the company officially enters into the new markets they want to be a contender in, there is a very real possibility that they will struggle. If they want to prevent this from happening, they need to step up their engagement, maximize their partnerships, and start responding to people.

My recommendations? Show off your customers! They have super great costumes and highlighting their contributions and love for Dunkin', aside from the sweepstakes winner, is a great way to engage the community.

Engage over multiple platforms! Twitter isn't enough to show you're present. Expand and connect.

Move away from America Runs on Dunkin' and go bigger. If you want to be a global company, prove it with inclusivity.

Reverse productions. Harpoon makes a Coffee Flavored Porter, Dunkin' should make a beer flavored donut (doesn't have to be just beer. Irish whisky or baileys could also go well). Cider Donuts and Pumpkin spice are a thing of the past; make way for the Beer Donut.

Anyways, that's my two cents on the matter, but hey, what do I know. I'm just a college student and I don't feel particularly engaged by my morning coffee.


Wednesday, October 10, 2018

Energizing and Revitalizing the communities we've built: A look into Pokemon Go

Creating a community is one of the most rewarding and difficult accomplishments a company can achieve. A community means that they've successfully built a brand that draws in loyal customers who want to be a part of the process. Sometimes those companies may struggle to engage their community, which is a big aspect of what our readings for chapters 5-8 in Groundswell: winning in a world transformed by social technology by Charlene Li and Josh Bernoff really focused on. Today I wanted to take a look at how a company can revitalize their audience and their Groundswell by finding creative ways to draw in new loyal customers. Specifically, I plan on diving a little deeper into the video game "Pokemon Go" and the efforts that Niantic, the founding company, has been doing to create a strong, engaged community.

The announcement trailer for Pokemon Go, way back in September 2015

Pokemon Go was released in the summer of 2016 and took the entire world by storm. The game uses the popular franchise, Pokemon, as it's basis for the app. For those who are unfamiliar, Pokemon or Pocket Monsters is a video game where users catch fantasy creatures, train them, and use them to battle others for the title of "Pokemon League Champion". The series has been incredibly popular over it's 20+ year run and continues to release new titles every single year. As of now, there are over 800 "Pokemon" that are available for capture. In Pokemon Go, players are encouraged to go outside and find Pokemon in parks, stores, and streets in their neighborhoods. The game takes the basic mechanics of Pokemon (I.E. capture Pokemon) and implements it into a real world style platform. Popular real world locations, such as churches or Sprint Stores, became marked in game as Pokestops or Gyms. Pokestops would give players items to use for capturing Pokemon, but could only be accessed if the player was in the vicinity.

Pokestops on the ingame map. More tend to appear in heavily populated locations

Gyms, however, were a whole new ballgame. Pokemon Go featured three different teams that players could choose to be a part of. These teams could use their Pokemon to take control of the various gyms. Players of opposing teams could then use their Pokemon to battle these gyms in a King of the Hill style match for control of the towers. This began to create some of the community aspect fans were desperate for; a way to turn a traditionally single player game into a collaborative experience.

The 3 different teams players could join and their respective controlled gyms.
White = unclaimed, Yellow = Instinct, Blue = Mystic, Red = Valor

Due to the series popularity and the level of engagement, Pokemon Go was an instant hit. Millions of users registered within the first few days of release. One of the most amazing things in those first weeks was seeing how many people, whether they had heard of the series or not, were playing this app. I'll never forget my friend texting me "we're going to go to the park and catch some Pokemon, want to come?". As someone who played these games religiously as a child, I was blown away with nostalgia and glee as I ran around town with my friends capturing Pokemon left and right. Everyone had their heads buried in their phones, yet we felt more connected than ever before. Players would come up to me, pointing me in the directions to find my next rarest Pokemon.

One example of a park a few days into the release of Pokemon Go

As time went on, the more dedicated gamers stuck around and continued to play. Parks became emptier, app usage went down, and Niantic recognized this. After using Pokemon Go for such a long time, players became bored with the content currently available. There was a lack of variety in the species that appeared in locations, especially with players in urban/suburban neighborhoods. This is when Niantic took a look at the Groundswell decided it was time to revitalize the community. When the game was originally released, there was an active decision made to have only the original 151 Pokemon inside the games network. This allowed for fans of the first released games to be incentivized to play (since the first generation of games only featured those original 151) as well as having some of the more commonly seen Pokemon available for newer players to recognize. In addition, it also helped Niantic cover their basis if the game wasn't successful. The less coding that went into the game, the easier it would be to shut down if it did not make monetary sense to continue operation. As a result, there were over 600 Pokemon that could be added into the database at any moment they wanted. Niantic used these as ways to drag the community back into its clutches.

Major release events soon became a common occurrence. Niantic would analyze their player database and use the statistics available to plan out events. Not only did the releases bring back users to the app, it also gave the dedicated fan base a reason to play again. Every time a new release or feature was added, a major spike in active users was seen. These events would either focus on making Pokemon that were more difficult to find commonly available or add new Pokemon into the already large ranks.

The promo photo from the Fire and Ice Solstice event focused on making both fire type and ice type pokemon, which were typically rare, easier to find for a few weeks.

While having new Pokemon to catch was great and all, the fans still felt as though there was a missing aspect to their community; the necessity to work together. Gyms have had varying success, although it became more of a competition to see who's Pokemon stayed in the longest. Niantic decided to energize the Groundswell once again, this time by creating Raid Battles. Raid Battles made collaboration a necessity, creating rare or uncommonly seen "bosses" that players could not take on alone. These raid bosses required upwards of 20 players working together to take down the tyrant. Should they be successful, players were then given the opportunity to catch these unique Pokemon and add them to their collection.

The release video that explained how Raid Battles worked

Niantic used a method similar to the case study on page of Groundswell: winning in a world transformed by social technology. In this case, Credit Mutuel asked their customers for ideas of how to improve their banking service. The bank decided it would listen to their clients and really focus on customer satisfaction. They analyzed the current state of their groundswell and looked to make improvements from the opinions that really mattered to them. Niantic noticed that their community wanted to work together and took Raids as an opportunity to make it a reality.

Did you ever play Pokemon Go, especially in it's craziest and most popular phase? What do you think Niantic can do next to engage more of a community?